Advertisement

Is the iPhone's predictive text too clever for its own good? Print
By Scott Colvey on Wednesday, 06 August 2008

iPhone Damiera error Imagine you wanted to use your iPhone to search for information on Buffalo-based experimental band, Damiera. Okay, so we know that you don’t want to do that but just imagine. Please?

Right, thanks. Now dig out your iPhone, fire up Safari and call up the search bar in the usual way. Type in "damiera" (without the quotes) and be careful not to make any mistakes. Did you make a mistake? We bet you did, even if you didn’t notice. Delete the word and try typing it again – and don’t be tempted to use backspace (you probably did the first time without even realising).

Try it letter by letter: D... A... M... I... and then what? If you manage to get past the ‘E’, you won’t get the ‘R’ – you’ll perhaps get a ‘T’. If you fail earlier, your ‘E’ might be an ‘R’. No matter what you try, the iPhone will not let you type ‘DAMIERA’ in one run without backspacing. Why? Well, our thoughts – and a video of the glitch in action – after the cut.

The iPhone’s predictive text is a clever thing, altering its key-detection area as you type. In other words, as you tap away, the detection area around some keys increases, while other decrease – the idea is that this makes it easier to type the word you want (or at least the one the iPhone thinks you want), no matter how bad your typing. And in this instance, it looks like the iPhone’s predictive text engine simply can’t cope with the idea that anyone might want to type the word "Damiera" – or even "Samiera" (which creates a different key confusion).

 

 

This fact has caused great frustration for poster Chaseforfeit over on Apple’s support forums, where we spotted this glitch. He runs a business called Damiera and is annoyed that he can’t type his company’s name in some situations. Other posters have now piled in with more examples.

So far, no-one’s discovered any proper English words that the iPhone won’t allow to be typed. However, if you want to find information on Damiera – business or band – you’ll need to use the backspace key...

Update: "Sesame" is another word that the iPhone reckons you won't want to search for, even though it suggests the word when you get to "ses"...

Update2: "Flickr" added to the list... (thanks to 'lewisking')

[Apple Support]

Trackback(0)
Comments (16)add comment
...
written by jim , August 07, 2008

learn how to type on your iphone and stop being a blinking moron. its a keyboard, you can type whatever you want on it. i just did on mine, worked fine. so did hundreds of others that saw / proceeded to make fun of you after reading your article.
report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: -2

...
written by Scott Colvey , August 08, 2008

Oh dear. Have you watched our video? Have you followed the link to the Apple Support forum that first highlighted the problem? We did not discover this problem - we merely reported on it having found other complainants and then yes, experiencing the same problem for ourselves.

I urge you to watch the video and, well, try it. You may find there's a different moron on the loose.

Scott.

report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: +1

...
written by Philpot , August 08, 2008

Jim,

You are the moron. I followed Scot's example and he's right. Others have the same problem so visit the Apple forum like he says and you'll see.,

report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: +0

...
written by M , August 12, 2008

with all due respect (and I dont own an iphone so I have no idea), but one would presume that like every other phone you can turn off the predictive text, no?
report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: +0

re:
written by dan , August 13, 2008

with all due respect (and I dont own an iphone so I have no idea), but one would presume that like every other phone you can turn off the predictive text, no?


no.

report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: +0

a-phone predictive text
written by robby , August 13, 2008

YAY! i love those sounds that Damiera make...they throw it down.

-'berto

report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: +0

...
written by Josh , August 17, 2008

Yes, there is a moron here, and it is you. You *cannot* type these words on the keyboard -- it will not let you.

You cannot type it on any iPhone without hitting the backspace. Before calling someone a moron, perhaps you should employ a little common sense and *actually* try it. This is a well known software glitch, and we thank Scott for pointing it out.

report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: +1

...
written by LatooijBoy , August 20, 2008

Without name calling I would just like to mention that i had no problems typing 'damiera' on my iPhone, pointing out that i have large hands. Also 'sesame' and 'flickr' I could type in without any difficulty/no backspace. I have the 16gig 3G iPhone, does that make any difference?

Greetings from the LowLands,
LatooijBoy

report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: +0

damiera
written by cristiano , August 20, 2008

I've just tried to type "damiera"- "sesame " and "flickr" on my 16Gb i-phone and it type them properly. I'm italian so the language is itaian , could it make difference?

Greetings from sweet lovely Italy

Cristiano

report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: +0

...
written by a guest , August 22, 2008

IHi Cristiano. Yes, the language makes a difference - different languages have different frequencies for adjacent letter strings. Apple's basically using it's word dictionary to see what words the user might be wanting to type. If you type "damie" into OSX's Dictionary application for English then only one choice comes up (Damietta, the eastern branch of the Nile delta if anyone's interested!). Since as far as the dictionary's concerned there's a 100% chance that the next letter typed is going to be a T, it makes the target area for the T key very big.

Apple's scheme is generally very clever. However, it falls down in situations where the dictionary doesn't have an entry: mainly unusual names, foreign words, and neologisms. The dictionary is pretty big though, as the example of Damietta illustrates.

One way around the problem is to stop making up silly words, or to check planned words against the dictionary ;) A bit of a hassle though. Luckily, in most cases the iPhone is quite clever about adding words to its custom dictionary - when you reject a suggested spelling correction, it adds the unknown word to the custom dict. Unfortunately, this doesn't work in the above case because the phone doesn't suggest an alternative - it forces one on you. It's a pretty rare occurrence, but really apple should allow you to add words to the custom dictionary. An idea for an application developer perhaps?

report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: +0

another: \"matrix\"
written by gregsparc , August 22, 2008

"matrix" is a goner, too...

It's pretty tough to talk about games-theory, or a state-machine chart, or a million other things.....

report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: +0

Spondylosis
written by a guest , August 27, 2008

I am having problems with medical words. I cannot type "spondylosis" and others. If there was a way to learn this word, maybe that would help, but predictive text won't learn these words that have to be misspelled first before corrected.
report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: +0

Pye
written by Willa , September 07, 2008

I have a cat named Pyewacket, Pye for short. If I type the word "Pye" as an email subject, my iPhone changes it to "Lye." EVERY freakin' time. She's sick, and I've been sending updates to people, invariably with the subject line, "Lye." :(
report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: +0

\"neat\" doesn\'t work, it\'s english
written by Ken Oporto , November 13, 2008

A normal proper english word "neat" cannot be typed.. the T is ignored and skips to the left or right just like your video.

Can anyone else type neat?

report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: +0

...
written by Scott Colvey , November 13, 2008

Interesting one, Ken. I can type 'Neat' as a first, capitalised word but *not* mid-sentence. Oddly, though, the iPhone then wants to correct 'neay', for example, to 'neat'. A good find, anyway!
report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: +0

For
written by Jake , December 17, 2008

whenever I try typing the word "for" i end up getting fir and have to backspace, tis annoying
report abuse
vote down
vote up

Votes: +1


Write comment
smaller | bigger
 

busy
 
< Prev   Next >

Top stories in the last 10 days

Advertisement

Latest news

VIA Nano confirmed as driving force behind Samsung NC20
It’s something of a struggle to find a netbook running off anything other than Intel’s Atom processor – be it the Atom 270 or 280....
Read more...
Solar powered batteries on show
Solar power is great and by all accounts is going to save the world from imploding on itself, but having to drag around a solar charging unit with y...
Read more...
Ultrathin netbooks on the way from Asus and Acer
The Chinese-language Commercial Times has just dropped word on not one but two manufacturers lining up ultra-thin netbooks. What with Chinese not qu...
Read more...
Motorola i465 shows off "pyramid" keyboard
First up - this isn't a phone we're going to see here anytime soon. Nor would we want to. It's the Motorola i465, designed for America's rather ...
Read more...
A million iPhones sold in UK
With double digit billion pound losses at our UK banks, some good news for a change. O2's parent company, Telefónica Europe, has announced pr...
Read more...
Gigabyte releases details of three new netbooks
CeBIT is almost upon us, and Gigabyte will be using the event to launch no less than three 10.1-inch netbooks – the Touch Note T1028, Booktop ...
Read more...
Google launches status dashboard for cloud tools
In case you didn’t know, Gmail went down earlier this week. It affected some members of the Mobile Computer team but we didn’t bother re...
Read more...
Microsoft planning skinny Windows 7 for netbooks
Microsoft has been raving about how the full-fat version of its forthcoming Windows 7 operating system will run without a hitch on the majority of n...
Read more...
Sennheiser upgrades your iPhone buds - work with MacBook too
Our traditional advice on opening an MP3 player is to file the bundled buds in the bin and grab a set of decent 'phones from the likes of Sennheiser...
Read more...
Windows Mobile 7 arriving 2010 - no Zune phone though
As sleep inducing as a Microsoft "Strategic Update Meeting" sounds, today's SUM (as we comatose regulars like to call them) has turned up ...
Read more...

Latest reviews

Hands-on with the Nokia E63
The E71 was – and still is – Nokia's flagship business smartphone and when it launched in late 2008, it had an unlocked price tag to mat...
Read more...
Hands-on with the Asus Eee PC T91 tablet netbook
We covered the Eee PC T91 back at its announcement at CES, but the dim, noisy venue meant that we couldn't get much in the way of clear photographs ...
Read more...
Hands-on with the Asus Eee PC 1000HE
We've been hearing some good things about the new Asus Eee PC 1000HE netbook – improved keyboard, bigger battery, better performance – b...
Read more...
Nokia 5800 XpressMusic
Nokia has shunned touch-screens so far for its smartphone output, but it’s clearly a technology whose time has (finally) come for the finicky ...
Read more...
Hands-on: How well does the Sony VAIO P Series handle streaming video?
It's turning into a VAIO P Series weekend here at Mobile Computer – yesterday we posted our photographs of Sony's ultra-ultraportable next to ...
Read more...
Hands-on with the Nokia 5800 XpressMusic phone
We were rather surprised to see a queue outside the Regent Street Nokia store for the UK launch of the XpressMusic 5800 last Friday, but it seems ...
Read more...
Hands-on with the Lenovo IdeaPad S10e netbook
We’ve been waiting for the Lenovo IdeaPad S10e netbook to turn up at the Mobile Computer office for a while, but it has now finally arrived....
Read more...
Hands-on with the HTC S740 smartphone
We liked the HTC S710 smartphone a lot when we reviewed it back in 2007 – the keyboard-only Windows Mobile Standard works much better than P...
Read more...
Dell Inspiron Mini 12
Netbooks are going to be big this year - in every sense of the word. Sensitive to complaints about small, low-resolution screens and ever-eager to i...
Read more...
Hands-on with the Dell Inspiron Mini 12
We’re just polishing off our review of the Dell Inspiron Mini 12, so here’s our first impressions video to tide you over in the meantim...
Read more...

Latest features

The Top 10 Mobile Computer stories of 2008
With 2008 almost at an end, we thought it would be a good time to take a look back over our most popular articles over the last 12 months &ndash...
Read more...
Netbook inventor not very impressed after waiting 40 years for first model
If you thought the netbook was a fresh and exciting idea only now made possible by innovative technological developments – think again. Alan...
Read more...
Why Apple's iPhone sales aren't really that RIMarkable
For anyone who's followed Apple's fortunes over the years, the transformation of the company has been remarkable. And that's not just a statement ab...
Read more...
5 reasons reading CrunchGear is a worse idea now than ever before
The folks over at CrunchGear have come up with five reasons for why damaging a MacBook "is a worse idea now than ever before". Go read the...
Read more...
Will Google's Android change the way we see the world?
So it is finally almost here. The T-Mobile G1, the first smartphone based on Google's Android operating system, is set to ship in the UK in early No...
Read more...

Latest comments

Sony Vaio P series will cost £849+ in UK!
Thanks Kral Fm KralFm
Hands-on with the Toshiba NB100 netbook
i hav nb 100 net book it is verry good net book so thank's toshiba
HTC Shift X9500 on sale at Expansys for £500
o mini pc i like
Solar powered batteries on show
http://www.questmonk.comLung cancer is the most common cancer world-wide with 1.4 million new cases ...
Expansys leaks info on clamshell BlackBerry 8210 and 8220
AG said Friday its drug Tarceva was shown to extend the lives of patients with lung cancer without t...
Netbook inventor not very impressed after waiting 40 years for first model
Hi i bought mobile broadband from http://www.domesticutilities.com and get free mini compaq nove lap...
Nokia announces N97 Symbian smartphone
Multi-tasking but low on RAM It is computer but you can't share internet. You can't get connected to...
Hands-on with the Toshiba NB100 netbook
recently brought my nb100 and its perfect except for sound i cant seem to get any tried the keys on ...
Google launches status dashboard for cloud tools
The Google Apps Status Dashboard came online in late February as a way of offering "performance info...
Download Windows 7 for free from tomorrow
Pless i want to full windows 7. send me to download link.(free Download)

Mobile Broadband

Compare prices

3G broadband dongles from 3, Vodafone, T-Mobile and Orange from just £10/month

Button link to Mobile Broadbandgenie.co.uk
Powered by Broadband Genie Broadband Genie logo

Advertisement

Dennis logo

Other Dennis Publishing technology sites you may be interested in: