Asus Eee PC 904
Review by Julian Prokaza on Mon 28 July 2008
Page 1 of 2
Summary
- Guide price
- £269
- Rating
4 out of 6- Good
- Great, big keyboard; 80Gb hard disk
- Bad
- Battery life not justified by extra bulk
- Verdict
- A nice option if you need a bigger keyboard and a low price, but the Eee PC 904’s battery life doesn’t quite warrant the extra bulk.
- Manufacturer
- Asus
Review
Well, this is it – the last Eee PC-branded ultra-portable that Asus will be launching. Well, for the time being, at least. As with the Eee PC 1000, the Eee PC 904 isn’t really anything new – it’s just a repackaging of existing components intended to fill what Asus perceives as a gap in its line-up.
We’re less convinced of the need for what is essentially an Eee PC 900 in an Eee PC 1000 shell (which is itself just a scaled-up Eee PC 901), but that’s only because better netbooks than this are available from other manufacturers – and Asus is hardly likely to worry about that.


The Eee PC 904 uses the same case as the Eee PC 1000, but the similarities are only skin-deep (you can watch our video comparison here). Inside, the 904 uses the same Intel Celeron-M chip as the Eee PC 900 rather than an Atom N270 processor, but this makes little difference to performance. In fact the 904 is rather faster than the 901 and a little quicker than the 1000, but we suspect these figures are due to the 904’s 80Gb hard disk being rather quicker at delivering data than the SSDs in the other two netbooks.

Unfortunately, that processor and hard drive do have an adverse effect on battery life and even with its 6600mAh cell, the Eee PC 904 can only manage four hours of light use. Now this isn’t bad per se, but it really doesn’t justify the extra weight that the battery adds – after all, the smaller, lighter Eee PC 900 only ran for 45 minutes less in the same test (and with a lower capacity battery, too); the marginally more expensive Eee PC 901 lasted for eight hours.

Still, the main reason for buying the Eee PC 904 is to get a bigger keyboard than that on the 900 and 904, and in this respect it doesn’t disappoint. The keyboard is the same as that on the Eee PC 1000, but we reviewed a pre-production version of that netbook and so couldn’t pass final judgement. Happily, the production keyboard on the 904 more than passes muster. There’s a little bit of flex at either end, but it’s certainly comparable to the keyboards on the MSI Wind U100 and Advent 4211 and is very comfortable to use. Oh and it has a full-size Enter key too, though the right-hand Shift key is still half the size it should be.

Recent reviews
Most popular netbooks
Asus Eee PC 904HD-W002X specification
- Processor
- Intel Celeron-M (900MHz)
- Memory
- 1Gb DDR2
- Graphics
- Intel GMA950
- Hard disk
- 80Gb
- Optical drive
- NA
- Floppy drive
- NA
- Screen
- 8.9in (1024 x 600)
- Connectivity
- 3 x USB 2.0, VGA, headphone, mic, 802.11g
- Other
- SD Card slot
- Operating system
- Windows XP Home
- Size
- 266 x 191 x 38mm
- Weight
- 1.36kg
- Battery life
- Light use: 4h 4m ; heavy use: 3h 6m
- DVD playback
- NA
Comments
The time lag between reviews like this and the product being available is, it seems, increasing. I've been looking out for an acceptable cheap notebook for months and everytime I think I've found one there's an announcement that makes me hold off. I decided the original EEE pc 701 keyboard was too small. As of today it's just not not possible to buy an EEE pc with a decent keyboard NOW, TODAY. It's delay, delay, delay.I'll probably end up buying something else. But rubbishing the 904 is wrong. If it was available TODAY I would buy it. But it's not available, so I'll wait. While I'm waiting something better will be announced and I'll wait a bit longer. I'll get tired of it in the end, and as soon as I buy something a serious vendor will announce a better product with immediate availability.sigh
The 1000 isn't available either.So all this sneak preview stuff here is a complete waste of time. This site would be a lot more useful if it simply refused to review products that were not available. Please consider it. PC Magazine at one point had a policy of not reviewing products that were not generally available.
How the heck is there such a performance difference between the 900 and the 904 if they are both using the Celeron? Is it clocked higher in the 904? What I really don't get is how the 904's multi-app performance is better than single app, when the 900 absolutely dies in multi app, when they are both supposedly using the same single core celeron. Something's fishy with this review.
As mentioned in the review, the difference in performance is due to a) the use of a hard disk in the 904 (SSD in the 900) and b) the fact (which we didn't mention) that the Windows XP 900 has no swap file by default.
Reviewing products *after* they go on sale wouldn't really make for news, now would it? In any case, the Eee PC 1000 is [url=http://www.ebuyer.com/product/146027]available now[/url], the 904 will be on sale in a few weeks.
