MSI Wind hands-on video and Aspire One/Eee PC 901 comparisons
By Julian Prokaza on Tuesday, 01 July 2008
With your appetite has been whetted by the Wind unboxing video, here comes the starter – a hands-on video of MSI’s new netbook. You can also see some side-by-side comparisons with the only other two Intel Atom-powered netbooks available at the moment – the Acer Aspire One and Asus Eee PC 901.
The MSI Wind is the netbook a lot of people have been holding on for, since it seems to combine all of the best features of other small, cheap ultraportables – a big screen, large keyboard, to name the two most notable.
We’ll be publishing a full review in the next day or so, so until then, you can read our first impressions after the cut.
The MSI Wind is the biggest of the three Intel Atom-powered netbooks we’ve seen so far, but not by much – it’s just 10mm wider than the Acer Aspire One. That extra centimetre is there for good reason, though – unlike the other 8.9in screen netbooks, the MSI Wind has a 10in, 1024 x 600 display.
Build quality feels very good – the Wind seems solidly made and there are no creaks in the case or unsightly gaps. The lid has the same glossy finish and sloped edges as the Acer Aspire One (a design touch we like) and the curved front edge of the base helps make the laptop look a little slimmer than it actually is.
That extra case width also means that MSI has been able to fit what is perhaps the best netbook keyboard we’ve seen so far. It’s much larger than that on the Eee PC and a little bigger than the Aspire One’s, and pretty comfortable to use as a result. Two very welcome touches are the oversize Enter and Backspace keys – other laptops this size have shrunken keys.
The extra 1.1in of the screen doesn’t make a huge amount of difference compared to the 8.9in screens on the Aspire One and Eee PC 901, but nor does it add much to the laptop’s bulk either. It’s extremely bright at its highest setting, but not quite off at its lowest and you’ll still be able to use it comfortably with the brightness cranked right down.
In terms of specification, the Wind is on a par with the competition – 1.6GHz Intel Atom N270, 1Gb RAM, Intel 945 graphics – but this model has an 80Gb hard disk. This makes Windows XP a much more viable proposition on a netbook – the Eee PC 901 really struggles to hold Windows XP and a handful of applications, even in its 20Gb (4Gb + 16Gb SSD) form. The drive on this review model was partitioned as a 39Gb C: drive and a 31.5Gb D: drive, though the second partition is empty.
Our review model has Microsoft Office 2007 installed, though I’m not certain whether this will be included with retail models – look for confirmation of that in the full review. Another uncertainty at this stage is the overclock/underclock button. As with the Eee PC 901, there’s a keyboard shortcut to underclock or overclock the Intel Atom processor, but it doesn’t appear to have any effect on our review MSI Wind. We’ll look into it and let you know what the deal is later.
We’ll be publishing a full review of the MSI Wind in the next day or so, but in the meantime, here’s a 10 minute tour of the netbook, along with some comparisons with the Acer Aspire One and Asus Eee PC 901.
Looks good.. and I need one... Does it sell with Linux? I am *not* paying a windows licence for a laptop that "cheap".
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
Please get a tripod written by C. Sick , July 02, 2008
Nice little overview of the Wind, but it would be much better if the video was steady, Between the bobbing and weaving of the camera, while waving around the system in front of the lens, and your habit to drifting to the right leaving the focus off-center, it made the whole experience painful to watch.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
Dude, get a tripod! written by Dave , July 02, 2008
Would help.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Wired Keyboard written by Good Review , July 02, 2008
Anyone notice that MSI Wind keyboard rearrange the key location for "@","#", and some other symbols.
That means SHIFT-2 is not "@" anymore, SHIFT-3 is not "#" anymore.
It is a BAD design and I don't like it.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Linux written by Nick , July 02, 2008
I'd only consider buying the MSI wind if I can get a version preinstalled with Linux. That said, I'll be getting the Acer Aspire One because it's cheaper, does come with Linux preinstalled and although the MSi has more storage I consider that a moot point since you could easily just get a couple of 16 - 32 GB USB memory sticks to expand the the available storage on any of these machines and even then the Acer will still be significantly cheaper. I find it difficult to understand why anyone would want one of these lovely little machines running such a horribly bloated and insecure system as windows.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Dummy written by a guest , July 02, 2008
This is the British version, they have a few keys in different places.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Enter Keys written by Lachlan Hunt , July 02, 2008
That's not a fair comparison between the Enter keys. The MSI keyboard looks like it's using the International English layout, whereas the other one is using the US Layout. Here's a picture of the MSI Wind with the US Layout.
re: Wired Keyboard written by Charlie Dobbie , July 02, 2008
Anyone notice that MSI Wind keyboard rearrange the key location for "@","#", and some other symbols.
That means SHIFT-2 is not "@" anymore, SHIFT-3 is not "#" anymore.
It is a BAD design and I don't like it.
Well, we don't like your keyboard layout either...
That's a UK keyboard layout. It's a standard Qwerty setup for the letters, but you'll spot a few differences in other characters - both quotes, pipe, at, hash, tilde, backslash are all placed differently, and we've got euro and sterling symbols added. Suffice to say, this device will be localized for the region it's being sold in - the US version will have the US layout you expect.
(Thanks goodness he wasn't reviewing a French model - you'd have gone through the roof with an Azerty layout...)
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
UK keyboard written by Ian Cummings , July 02, 2008
@Good Review - it's not a bad design of keyboard; it's a UK British keyboard!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Re: Wired Keyboard written by Jim , July 02, 2008
Anyone notice that MSI Wind keyboard rearrange the key location for "@","#", and some other symbols.
Shift-3 is , Shift2 is ". @ and # over above right shift. Standard UK keyboard layout.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
The Keyboard written by Jonas , July 02, 2008
The keyboard is a standard UK layout and as such, isn't a bad design ;-)
Presumably when it is released in the US, they'll come equipped with the appropriate layout for that market.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
re: Wired Keyboard written by Gatesy , July 02, 2008
Anyone notice that MSI Wind keyboard rearrange the key location for "@","#", and some other symbols.
That means SHIFT-2 is not "@" anymore, SHIFT-3 is not "#" anymore.
It is a BAD design and I don't like it.
Looks like the UK standard (and same as my Eee) to me. shift 2 = " Shift 3 = pound sign.
Once again we're stuck in rip off Britain - in the US, the linux version costs $399 but in the UK it costs 319!
According to US pricing, it should only cost us 200. I`ll be buying internationally I think.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Yukc.. reversed Ctrl & Fn keys.. written by Nicholas , July 02, 2008
That's a big pain in the left hand. I'll buy the Acer or the new Eee pc 1000 just because of that point.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
... written by Anon Coward , July 02, 2008
Really, was this filmed by the blair witch crew? How 'bout you invest in a tripod.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Pay attention to your camera work. written by a guest , July 02, 2008
What is the point of making these video reviews if you take no efforts to do it with any level of quality at all. Just because you're a computer geek doesn't mean you have to make a point of making terrible video recordings.
and I never even post comments to reviews.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
battery written by ANON , July 02, 2008
one of the most important items on my list is battery life. From the pics looks like the Asus EeePC ships with 6600Mah with everyone else going for a 2200mah battery this and the flash drive will likely make it my choice.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
I Feel... written by A Sick Sailor , July 02, 2008
Sea Sick after watching this video.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1
... written by Mike Silva , July 02, 2008
Yeap, I could consider the Wind if there was a Linux version on time in my country. Last time I checked, the Eee 701 just came last week (it was 9 months late) and still no signs of other Asus newer models:(Portugal) Since Acer is planing a good Linux aspire one this month, I'm betting my money on ONE.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Speakers written by Doctor_WHO , July 02, 2008
The reviewer noted that the speakers were facing the desk - and implied that they would sound poor in part, because of that.
I think the curved frame would make the audio reflect off the desk increasing the sound quality.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
... written by The Doctor\'s Companion , July 02, 2008
Maybe if you use your sonic screwdriver on the speakers you'll get a better kick out of them Doc.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
this video makes me laugh so hard written by d-rizzle , July 02, 2008
this is so funny - the way the guy records and he punches the keys on the keyboards like hes poking the Pillsbury doughboy
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
... written by Grant , July 02, 2008
Yes, the MSI Wind ships pre-installed with SUSE Linux Enterprise Desktop from Novell starting in July (according to the MSI website):
http://www.msimobile.com/nblist.aspx?series=U
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Desktop Linux on Wind written by Grant , July 02, 2008
The MSI Wind comes pre-installed with SUSE Linux Enterprise Desktop from Novell (and will be released in July according to the MSI website):
http://www.msimobile.com/nblist.aspx?series=U
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
barf.. ok better now written by warden , July 02, 2008
horrible camera work. Plz no more blair witch camera work. buy a dam tripod!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
... written by David George , July 02, 2008
I've just had to go and barf, the worst video I've seen. Get a goddam tripe yer yellow toothed limey.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
... written by Lazo , July 02, 2008
I feel sick watching this video, u move the camera too much..., but, thanks for the review
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
... written by a guest , July 02, 2008
Thanks for the review. Very interesting and very good info. Although I agree with some of the less strident tripod comments, I appreciate your time and trouble. :-)
As several people have mentioned, as long is it's a Microsoft-only choice on operating systems, I too will have to look elsewhere. But nonetheless, it's very nice looking hardware.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
.. which means you are paying a licence anyway written by Frames , July 02, 2008
You'll pay that license to Novell, not Microsoft, but there is one cost. The same is true for Xandros and the Eee PC and for Linpus and the Aspire One.
Linux does not have to be free as in beer ... nor it has to be free as in freedom sometimes (there's proprietory items in Xandros and other Linux distros).
Having said that, I'm quite happy Linux comes pre-installed in these little puppies, rather than Windows.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
... written by Chuck , July 03, 2008
I'd really like to know how they compare in weight. An extra inch, and a hard drive v. a solid state drive might make a difference. From 2 lbs. to 3 lbs would be bad. 2 to 4 really changes things.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
It does come preinstalled with Linux. written by Bob , July 03, 2008
It DOES come with Linux; you just have to wait a bit longer for those units to launch. Even if it didn't, it's not as if the system is locked down to any particular OS. Stick whatever you want on there.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
... written by StratSynth , July 03, 2008
I wonder how many Macbooks it took to create this machine...
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Thanks, but why no tripod? written by Greg Conquest , July 06, 2008
Thanks for this video, but why didn't you use a tripod? Even if you're using a mobile phone camera with no tripod mount, you can still get little tripod-mount clamps . . .
Regarding the PC's, I hope for two things from netbooks: - Ubuntu netbook redux. It is a more standard and open OS. - and a VIA chip (OpenBook) It is a more standard, flexible, and open hardware platform.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
... written by JimG , July 06, 2008
Yes, but they shortchange you with Linux.
You only get 512K ram & NO bluetooth.
At least you don't have Windows, but geez ...
Personally, for the kinds of uses I have in mind for this type of device, I'd just as soon have the solid state drive too.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
... written by Julian Prokaza , July 06, 2008
Well, I was going for a kind of Cloverfield aesthetic, but thinking about it, that film made me feel a little queasy too. Fine, I'll use a tripod from now on...
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
... written by Mif , July 17, 2008
It's not a bad design, it's English. And we can spell...
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Linux pre-installed? written by nomorecorsa , July 17, 2008
A lot of remarks here about pre-installed Linux. You can always buy a laptop and install it yourself, so I don't get it...
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
yes, it is needed written by Greg Conquest , July 23, 2008
@nomorecorsa
No, you can't always install it yourself. Webcams, digitizers, video cards, . . . the list of components that don't have readily available linux drivers is lengthy enough, with problems common enough, to make your claim, "you can always install it yourself" absurd.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
... written by bludder , August 20, 2008
Now MSI has launched the Wind with Novell Linux, great, but then only with the 3-cell battery even if you can get the 6 cell if you buy the Windows version. Sure I can replace Windows with Linux, but why do I need to pay to Microsoft to get a 6cell battery?
VIA Nano confirmed as driving force behind Samsung NC20
It’s something of a struggle to find a netbook running off anything other than Intel’s Atom processor – be it the Atom 270 or 280....
Read more...
Solar powered batteries on show
Solar power is great and by all accounts is going to save the world from imploding on itself, but having to drag around a solar charging unit with y...
Read more...
Ultrathin netbooks on the way from Asus and Acer
The Chinese-language Commercial Times has just dropped word on not one but two manufacturers lining up ultra-thin netbooks. What with Chinese not qu...
Read more...
Motorola i465 shows off "pyramid" keyboard
First up - this isn't a phone we're going to see here anytime soon. Nor would we want to. It's the Motorola i465, designed for America's rather ...
Read more...
A million iPhones sold in UK
With double digit billion pound losses at our UK banks, some good news for a change. O2's parent company, Telefónica Europe, has announced pr...
Read more...
Gigabyte releases details of three new netbooks
CeBIT is almost upon us, and Gigabyte will be using the event to launch no less than three 10.1-inch netbooks – the Touch Note T1028, Booktop ...
Read more...
Google launches status dashboard for cloud tools
In case you didn’t know, Gmail went down earlier this week. It affected some members of the Mobile Computer team but we didn’t bother re...
Read more...
Microsoft planning skinny Windows 7 for netbooks
Microsoft has been raving about how the full-fat version of its forthcoming Windows 7 operating system will run without a hitch on the majority of n...
Read more...
Sennheiser upgrades your iPhone buds - work with MacBook too
Our traditional advice on opening an MP3 player is to file the bundled buds in the bin and grab a set of decent 'phones from the likes of Sennheiser...
Read more...
Windows Mobile 7 arriving 2010 - no Zune phone though
As sleep inducing as a Microsoft "Strategic Update Meeting" sounds, today's SUM (as we comatose regulars like to call them) has turned up ...
Read more...
Latest reviews
Hands-on with the Nokia E63
The E71 was – and still is – Nokia's flagship business smartphone and when it launched in late 2008, it had an unlocked price tag to mat...
Read more...
Hands-on with the Asus Eee PC T91 tablet netbook
We covered the Eee PC T91 back at its announcement at CES, but the dim, noisy venue meant that we couldn't get much in the way of clear photographs ...
Read more...
Hands-on with the Asus Eee PC 1000HE
We've been hearing some good things about the new Asus Eee PC 1000HE netbook – improved keyboard, bigger battery, better performance – b...
Read more...
Nokia 5800 XpressMusic
Nokia has shunned touch-screens so far for its smartphone output, but it’s clearly a technology whose time has (finally) come for the finicky ...
Read more...
Hands-on: How well does the Sony VAIO P Series handle streaming video?
It's turning into a VAIO P Series weekend here at Mobile Computer – yesterday we posted our photographs of Sony's ultra-ultraportable next to ...
Read more...
Hands-on with the Nokia 5800 XpressMusic phone
We were rather surprised to see a queue outside the Regent Street Nokia store for the UK launch of the XpressMusic 5800 last Friday, but it seems ...
Read more...
Hands-on with the Lenovo IdeaPad S10e netbook
We’ve been waiting for the Lenovo IdeaPad S10e netbook to turn up at the Mobile Computer office for a while, but it has now finally arrived....
Read more...
Hands-on with the HTC S740 smartphone
We liked the HTC S710 smartphone a lot when we reviewed it back in 2007 – the keyboard-only Windows Mobile Standard works much better than P...
Read more...
Dell Inspiron Mini 12
Netbooks are going to be big this year - in every sense of the word. Sensitive to complaints about small, low-resolution screens and ever-eager to i...
Read more...
Hands-on with the Dell Inspiron Mini 12
We’re just polishing off our review of the Dell Inspiron Mini 12, so here’s our first impressions video to tide you over in the meantim...
Read more...
Latest features
The Top 10 Mobile Computer stories of 2008
With 2008 almost at an end, we thought it would be a good time to take a look back over our most popular articles over the last 12 months &ndash...
Read more...
Netbook inventor not very impressed after waiting 40 years for first model
If you thought the netbook was a fresh and exciting idea only now made possible by innovative technological developments – think again. Alan...
Read more...
Why Apple's iPhone sales aren't really that RIMarkable
For anyone who's followed Apple's fortunes over the years, the transformation of the company has been remarkable. And that's not just a statement ab...
Read more...
5 reasons reading CrunchGear is a worse idea now than ever before
The folks over at CrunchGear have come up with five reasons for why damaging a MacBook "is a worse idea now than ever before". Go read the...
Read more...
Will Google's Android change the way we see the world?
So it is finally almost here. The T-Mobile G1, the first smartphone based on Google's Android operating system, is set to ship in the UK in early No...
Read more...